I think I mentioned last week that I made a cake for Children's Day. It was quite an experience, that cake-making event. I didn't think it would be since I tend to be good at making desserts and baked goods. I mean, how hard could it be to make two round layers of cake out of a box and then whip up some frosting and ice it? I've done tons of cakes before that were way more complicated. Yet, this experience takes a special place in my heart. Sort of like the scar tissue resulting from a heart attack has a special place.
It started out easy enough. It being fall and all, I decided to make a butter cake. Out of the box. No problem. Sunday night, two 8" round cake pans, about 55 minutes, voila, they came out perfectly. I put them on the cooling rack overnight. The next morning they still looked perfect and I was ready to frost the sucker and call it a successful Children's Day.
I whipped a cookbook off the shelf, the Southern Heritage Cake Cookbook, published by Southern Living in 1970. I received it secondhand from a friend whose mother had purged it from her massive gourmet kitchen when she divorced and left Texarkana for Australia for good. If anyone knows how to do a good cake, it's Southern Living. (Be careful, though. Those Southerners do
Coca-Cola Cake too, and we all know that don't come out so well.) In the last chapter, "Finishing touches," dozens of frosting and icing recipes come to life on the pages. There, on the first page of text, I saw it. The answer to my autumn cake dilemma. What kind of frosting should I put on a butter cake? Why, Caramelized Frosting.

Not only did the recipe call for only three ingredients, the recipe included step by step directions, complete with photographs. Yippee! What could be easier? And it sounded luscious. A caramelized frosting over butter cake. Perfect for fall. After reading through the recipe to make sure I felt confident, I dug in.
Mix together butter and sugar until a syrup. Slowly add milk. Yep, uh-huh, I'm with you entirely. Now, keep stirring and simmer the mixture until it reaches the soft ball stage, about 240 degrees F. I don't have a candy thermometer, but I know how to test when a mixture reaches the soft ball stage. Got it. The recipe read that it would take 20 minutes, but after only 10, that syrup was definitely at soft ball stage.
That's when the fun began. The recipe said I should remove the pan from the heat and mix in the pan with a hand mixer until the frosting reached the desired consistency for frosting.

Well, I did my cooking in a teflon pan, not an iron skillet, so I'll be damned if I'm going to risk ruining my pan with a mixer. Then there's the matter of a hand mixer. I don't have one. I have a super duper 600 hp KitchenAid mixer, made to handle any mixing needs you might have. So I lifted that skillet up off the burner, poured the mixture into the mixing bowl and immediately started mixing.
Perfect. It looked perfect. I was starting to imagine how good this was going to taste.
For those of you who cook, you may be thinking something here. Something like this: "Heather, it sounds like you just made caramel candy, not a frosting. Are you sure that this stuff is actually going to spread onto the cake?"
The picture in the recipe of the finished cake looked so easy to obtain.

And yet...
Oh, if you are one of those people who realized my mistake as reading this, I wish you had been there to tell me that
before I began this adventure. Indeed, I had made a huge mixer bowlful of caramel candy. It was only at the point I began trying to apply said candy to the cake in a frosting-like manner that I realized just what a mistake I had made. It probably was the difference of 30 or 45 seconds too long heating in the skillet. Or maybe it was taking the mixture cooling down while it was mixing. No matter what the tiny mistake was, I was now in quite a pickle, my great grandmother would have said.
The "frosting" was turning solid within seconds. I realized I'd better move fast, like ice this whole cake in 3 minutes or less, otherwise I'd REALLY have a mixing bowl full of solid caramel candy. I slapped it on the first layer then threw the second layer on top as fast as I could. I continued feverishly frosting the top layer and the sides, little by little. It got to solid to do anything with. Undeterred, I put all remaining "frosting" in a pyrex measuring cup and microwaved it for 15 seconds. Voila! I got soft frosting again. But it only would stay that way for a minute tops. I tried it once more and managed to finish the job. Here is what it looked like:


Not bad. I mean, not exactly professional quality, but not bad given what I just explained as to the cake's origins.
Whew.
Or so I thought. We gathered as a family that night to celebrate. A good dinner, gifts for the girls, and then...cake! We lifted the dome off of the cake plate and everyone smelled the cake. And then, we got out our sharpest knife, ran it under hot water, and tried to slice through the frosting. No way. That frosting, unsurprisingly, had hardened into a toffee shell, encasing the cake. After five minutes or so, we realized we should put aside good manners and try to get the cake out at all costs. We all had a piece, but I can't say it was pretty.
It was very tasty, though. And very sugary and chewy. We all brushed our teeth very well that night.
People, after this fiasco, I'm over my sugar fix. That was just a bit too much. It's sort of like making your kid smoke 200 cigarettes after you catch them with the first, right? You make them feel so sick that they can't associate a cigarette with anything but nausea? I wasn't nauseous, but I sure haven't been craving as much sugar since then.